Since the Walt Disney Company’s first animated feature in 1938, “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs,” the company has recently expanded its franchise by remaking its other famous animated originals into live-action adaptations. However, this rise of live-action movies has mostly sparked criticism rather than praise from their faithful audience. 

Disney, as a brand, is advertised for their famous characters and entertainment works, sparking magic and attraction from different generations. From her perspective, sophomore Leah Kim shares her opinion of Disney’s purpose.

“The purpose of Disney was to give the people a chance to be [themselves] and make their inner child happy,” Kim said. “Detach from the political world, or reality to enjoy [their] own fantasies, imagination and creativity.” 

According to IMDb, there are over 25 live-action remakes of Disney animated films, and more are predicted to be released in the future. English teacher Kirsten McKay, an avid Disney fan since childhood, assumes this rising trend is specifically targeted to Disney’s loyal fans. 

“They definitely bank on [nostalgia] for marketing to my generation because I’m a late millennial,” McKay said. “That is how they go ahead and try to get you because they recognize that the parents now want to share the same stories that [they] grew up with their kids, and that’s a huge cornerstone of their marketing.”

Relying on that nostalgia, Disney has gained successful box office profits from their live-action remakes, grossing over $1 billion in profits, according to IMDb. Despite these profits, junior Eli Stachnick believes the live-action remakes can never fulfill the success of the original animated movies due to the lack of individuality. 

“The [movies] have their own story and their own ending, and I think that’s what made them good, not the stories themselves,” Stachnick said. “Disney adding its own special charm and fantastical elements to [the movies] is what made it fun [whereas] trying to recreate that isn’t exciting, because it’s just a recreation.”

Similarly, Kim has noticed that the more live-action movie remakes are released, the more Disney’s famous charm is lost. 

“At first — Walt Disney — when he created Disney, he had so [much] imagination and creativity,” Kim said. “But now, I feel [Disney Studios] are starting to lose that creativity.” 

McKay, who has a child, has noticed Disney has adjusted to their new audience — Gen Alpha children. She thinks Disney does so by reviving past animated films to attract this audience. When creating these adaptations, younger audiences lack the ‘childhood movies’ that a generation can connect with. 

Stachnick believes Disney would have more success by creating original movies rather than depending on its old successes to connect with the younger generations. 

“If Disney were to create new movies, it would create a new generation of movie watchers,” Stachnick said. “Every generation would have a certain number of movies that they could relate to because they grew up watching them. Trying to recreate them kind of grazes that out; it doesn’t create any speciality in what Disney movies people know, see and love.”

A Bear Witness Instagram poll determined that 78% of 144 responders do not enjoy Disney’s live-action remakes. 

“Disney’s in a weird position where if they play it too safe, people call them out on it, but then if they change too much, people also call them out on it,” McKay said. “So, you get these weird middle grounds that these productions are in where you can tell that they’re trying to make everybody happy, and it’s not necessarily something that’s possible.”

From a student’s perspective, Kim dislikes Disney’s attempts to infuse remakes with new ideas.

“They have been trying to change a bit of the live original movies [remakes] into something different because of politics or controversies, so I think it’s starting to lose its whimsy,” Kim said.

More specifically, Kim disliked the live-action remake of “Snow White” released in 2025 since Snow White’s character in the recent film strays from the original Disney princesses’ confidence with their femininity to connect with today’s view on femininity. She believes these changes did the opposite of Disney’s intention. 

“Disney princesses carry themselves with femininity and with such strength,” Kim said. “I feel like [their characters] are just so admiring how they could stay hopeful, optimistic and kind throughout those hardships. It’s just amazing.”

With some of the remakes receiving praise, Kim believes they were successful because they expanded beyond their set storyline and gave new life to the films. 

“For example, Cinderella, Maleficent and Beauty and the Beast [remakes] have been doing it so well,” Kim said. “They have not only stuck with this story plot, but have really given us a deep dive into the characters and the relationships and how they start to get their character growth.” 

With Disney planning future projects of more live-action adaptations, many consumers like  Stachnick and Kim claim they struggle to feel the same connection to the well-known “Disney charm” as when watching the original animated films. 

“Now these days, I feel live action movies are starting to lose their popularity [and] lose their audience because you don’t have that sense of magic in that movie anymore,” Kim said.

Show Comments

Leave a Reply

0