In recent months, controversy surrounding the leaks of information gathered by age verification methods have provoked online backlash from users and parents alike.
These age verification methods have been praised and criticized in their introduction to online platforms. It has worked in protecting kids from strangers by enacting stricter policies on the content being published, but it has also made users distrust these methods through its weak security systems and its inability to correctly identify the user’s age.
A recent cyber attack on Discord that potentially leaked over 70,000 ID photos led to outrage from online users against the use of ID and age verification methods. Computer science teacher Steven Turner has been affected by data leaks in his Bank of America information and his Discord account.
“Last year alone, I was part of four data breaches, ranging from my Bank of America to 23andMe,” Turner said. “It just comes down to which [apps] do you actually need.”
With many online users concerned about the leaks, sophomore Ryan Wang says that age verification methods are necessary to block younger kids online, even if leaks might come with it.
“Some people do believe it’s a good idea because it protects kids,” Wang said. “Especially younger kids who don’t really know their way around the internet that well [and] from being chased or harassed by people outside their age range.”
Many companies have reverted to using AI to simplify the process of verifying ages.
“The AI has to be trained to check for birthdays on the ID if that would be provided,” Wang said. “AI should perhaps train to handle [leak] cases as well.”
But when protecting kids’ safety, it also blocks teens who are still under 18 from video because they haven’t verified their age using things like an ID or passport. One such teen is sophomore Owen Lundgren, who still can’t view certain videos his friends send him due to not verifying his age on Instagram.
“I’m almost going to be 17, and I think I am able to look at swear words and stuff,” Lundgren said. “If a kid’s younger than [me], maybe there should be more options, and it should be more of a spectrum.”
Turner has also run into this trouble when trying to play the Sesame Street Podcast on a Spotify kids account for his young daughter.
“I get the intent, but they’re not spending the resources to actually look up what [it is], they’re just looking for keywords,” Turner said. “Unless someone has reported this video specifically, is [it] not okay for people under the age of 18 [or] 13?”
Although teens like Lundgren are frustrated with their implementation, he says that these methods are important to prevent vulgar or insensitive language for children to listen if they encounter it online.
“People can see messed up stuff sometimes, and that’s pretty bad,” Lundgren said. “Even though I find it annoying sometimes, there’s other people who it would actually affect, just like younger [children].”
Although these age verification methods have brought scrutiny and online criticism for their implementations, Wang says that these age verification methods are for the better, and their security will improve over time.
“It can be helpful, especially with child-like [media] or websites with multiple age ranges coexisting on one platform,” Wang said.



Leave a Reply