Clubs, sports and other extracurriculars across Branham have been dealing with the new restrictions on communication platforms like Band, Remind and Instagram since the new usage bans this school year.

As of July 1, the Campbell Union High School District officially required all extracurriculars using Band, a communication app, to find an alternative form of communication. The policy made StudentSquare, a branch of the app ParentSquare, the district-approved choice. Although the policy was approved over the summer, implementation varied by school and group.

Activities director Victoria Raineri shared her outlook on the restrictions. While sports mainly use Band, many clubs on campus use Instagram to send out information to club members. Raineri explained that Band and Instagram do not follow the CUHSD guidelines that protect students’ data, while StudentSquare does. Band declined to sign a contract that said they could not share or use information pertaining to students that was shared when they were messaging.

“The district wants to protect students, and other platforms don’t have the same protections that StudentSquare and our Gmail accounts do,” Raineri said. “At the end of the day, it’s about protecting students’ privacy and making sure that we are having appropriate conversations and appropriate communication between the school and students.”

The Branham Royal Alliance Marching Band was among the earliest to adopt the new policy, having dropped the app over the summer. In contrast, groups like Girls’ Tennis continued to use Band for preseason communication. Senior Chloe Gao, a member of both groups, shared her experiences.

“I personally don’t like it, but I’m adjusting so far,” Gao said. “It hasn’t been horrible… I think that overall it makes communication a lot more difficult.”

The most commonly cited issue with StudentSquare is the communication obstacle it creates between coaches, supervisors and fellow students.

For sophomore and student-athlete Nube Ceniceros, the restriction affected how efficiently she could contact the Field Hockey team.

“I have a seventh period, and I’m always late [to practice],” Ceniceros said. “It’s hard for me to communicate … to tell them in advance ‘Oh, I’m going to be late this day,’ or, ‘I might not be able to come.’”

Gao believes the platform’s design lacks autonomy for students, particularly leaders. Though she stated many of the inner workings of StudentSquare were similar to the Band App, she noticed that students are unable to do things on their own, such as create announcements or submit files.

“It’s a lot less efficient and a lot slower, especially because we don’t have big group chats anymore where we can send out information,” Gao said.

Both Ceniceros and Gao expressed concerns about how StudentSquare’s interface hinders the ability to reach specific groups of people. Ceniceros noted feeling overwhelmed with the way StudentSquare pushes schoolwide events to users. 

“I just want to focus more on my clubs and my sports,” Ceniceros said. “I feel like that’s the main focus. Not in a disrespectful way, but I don’t want to know about everything that’s going on. I want to know what my games and practices are.”

While trying to create smaller sub-groups on StudentSquare, Gao experienced many inconveniences.

“Every time you want to create a new group, you have to go through the school and request that,” Gao said. “It takes a really long time for them to process that [and] for you to get people added onto it.”

Raineri understands that the change to StudentSquare is causing dilemmas for students and teachers, but she is hopeful that in the future everyone will adjust and be able to communicate without problems.

“Students that are new to our school can go to our club website and see all of the different club options and join them immediately, and then start getting information as soon as possible.” Raineri said. “Instead of trying to figure out who’s in charge of what, when do they meet, being a part of the Student Square group that [information] should all be available to them.”

Music teacher and head of marching band Andrew Kuykendall commented on the difficulty of switching apps during the adjustment period. Kuykendall specified that they would continue using Band until the July 1 deadline had passed. The viable alternative at the time — mass emails — was inefficient for the large group because it was time consuming. 

“Instead of being able to go on Band app and send some posts, I had to go through a process of copying chunks of emails at a time,” Kuykendall said. 

Kuykendall also expressed his concerns regarding using Parent and StudentSquare for communication between him and his students.

“Marching band has so many branches of different things that we have to work on,” Kuykendall said. “We have to split our long rehearsals up differently. So not being able to communicate that as easily has been a really big problem, especially when I put something in StudentSquare.”

Cross country runner and junior Jacob Harper has used Band throughout high school, explaining that when the switch to StudentSquare was implemented, he felt very overwhelmed with the combination of notifications from school and sports. When Harper tried finding his notifications for sports, they got lost with other notifications regarding news about the rest of school. 

“Not a lot of kids use [StudentSquare] because it’s just another thing they have to do, and Band was pretty straightforward,” Harper said. “So I think people aren’t going to be as responsive to notifications and emails and posts like they were on Band.” 

Furthermore, Raineri finds the clubs’ use of Instagram unfair to students who don’t use social media.

“Not every student has an Instagram account, so to only put information on Instagram is not reaching all of our students that need that information,” Raineri said. “But by putting it onto StudentSquare, which is the district-approved platform, it is able to get to all students.”

Cross country runner, club president, and senior Charlotte Homer was told the details of the switch to StudentSquare months ago, at the club presidents’ meeting. While Instagram can still be used, it will have more restrictions and need to go through StudentSquare first.

 At the club presidents’ meeting, some of my friends that I’ve talked to [were] like, ‘it’s a big adjustment.’” Homer said. “We’re so used to using Instagram to communicate, and also it’s a lot [harder] to do something through a separate platform … overall, it’s been inconvenient.”

The switch from platforms like Band and Instagram to StudentSquare has received a lot of negative feedback; however, Kuykendall believes the change can be beneficial as well.

“It’s a new program … and in a few years, it’ll be just as good as Band,” Kuykendall said. “What sucks now is we’re taking the hit for the future.”

Illustration by Annette Aguilar/Bear Witness

Show Comments

Leave a Reply

0