Meta, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook, agreed on up to a $17 billion landmark settlement and to alter their addictive algorithms after being sued by 47 of the 50 states for its mental health harm of children and teens, according to PBS.
BBC News explained that some of the states that sued are asking Meta to eliminate like counts, the endless scroll feature, appearance-altering filters, the ability to create multiple accounts, video autoplay and temporary “ephemeral” posts like stories. In addition, they want Meta to establish a parent verification system for children and teens, and to rework their dopamine-driven, addictive algorithm.
For children and teens, social media has been ever present in their lives, with 40% of children ages 8-12 using social media apps, even when the usual age limit is 13, according to Internet Safety 101. A Bear Witness Poll of 135 users found that 94% of students use Meta apps often.
Senior Keira Bloom believes that the lawsuit addresses how companies like Meta should prioritize the wellbeing of their consumers over their profit.
“[The suits are] valid if they’re purposely having addicting algorithms because I understand having people looking at your stuff and being on your app is how you make money,” Bloom said. “But I think it gets to a point where if something is too addicting, it becomes harmful and it’s doing more harm than good.”
Branham Psychologist McKenna Anderson explained how social media addiction is linked to the high reward of dopamine release from using the apps, and that creates addiction as teens want to keep feeling that.
“The more you spend time on social media, the more dopamine your brain gets, and then the more you crave that dopamine effect, the more you’ll use social media,” Anderson said. “It’s kind of like a reciprocal effect. It keeps going and going and going.”
According to the CDC, for the years 2023 to 2024, more than one in five children ages three through 17 were diagnosed with a mental, emotional or behavioral condition. This vulnerable part of the population is also experiencing the most addiction to Meta apps and social media.
As the brain is not fully developed until the age of 25, Anderson asserts that this period in the brain is when social-emotional concerns like anxiety and depression can arise. In addition, she notes that the teen period in the brain is centered around ego and comparison. Meta apps manipulate both of these things directly through their algorithm.
“The brain’s not fully developed, so it really relies on impulse control and decision making, and it doesn’t quite have the ability to weigh those factors, so it gets dopamine and it doesn’t regulate itself,” Anderson said. “Teenagers are like, ‘Nope, this feels good, I’m gonna keep doing it’ because they don’t have as many responsibilities and they can really indulge in social media and things like that.”
Junior Luke Deans observes how, especially in the Silicon Valley with high living costs and intense work ethic, students are given overly high expectations, which is a problem heightened through social media.
“Social media gives people unrealistic expectations for themselves,” Deans said. “People love to post all their achievements and success while hiding the work and failure it took to get there. Thus, when people go on social media and compare themselves to others, they may feel insignificant or like they have failed in some way.”
On Meta apps, people often share their lives while being exposed to standards created online. Bloom describes how these ideals are constantly pushed on people and especially women.
“For women, there’s certain standards they need to meet, that involve appearance or how they act and things like that,” Bloom said. “Societal standards for how much money people should have, or what vacations they should be on, or what products they have
From the increase in insecurities and stressors by Meta, senior Anna Szegedi feels that these apps can make teens less motivated to stay focused on their schoolwork or cope with those stressors by going back on social media. She adds that people can often feel insecure, jealous and envious even when they go to social media for validation.
“Because of the addictive nature of social media, they want to speed through learning and get over that,” Szegedi said. “Either that, or just post when they want to procrastinate, or hide from their troubles to just go into social media.”
According to PubMed Central, there is a correlation between pandemics and social media use as communication through social media grew during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Bloom expressed that the COVID-19 pandemic was what skyrocketed the addiction to social media apps and depending on them for socializing. With young brains developing without the ability to socialize face-to-face, this generation of students has been met with socializing difficulties as they’ve grown.
“Especially during COVID, I feel like people were so in their homes, which led them to be so online that it was kind of weird going back to normal and talking to people,” Bloom said. “Having to depend on not thinking about what you’re gonna say for a long time before sending it, and really just returning back to normal conversations in life [was hard].”
In order to make Meta apps more suitable for adolescents, Anderson feels that there should be more strict limits on unnecessary notifications and time spent on the app to lessen the Meta app effects.
“I know I have set a time limit for myself for one hour a day on TikTok and Instagram that I continue to click ‘ignore’ every single day,” Anderson said. “Blocking it and not having the ability to decline it and ignore it yourself might be helpful.”
As other social media apps like TikTok and Snapchat have similar effects on teens, Anderson finds that attention to the algorithms of Meta apps should inspire them to change as well.
“I would say if Instagram is doing it, then maybe the other [social media platforms] can learn from Instagram and make those changes to better support the children, adolescents and adults,” Anderson said.
Szegedi thinks that teens should try to limit the use of these apps and gear their goals toward a more authentic life.
“[Teens should] be taking advantage of the opportunities that you can hang out with others your age in person, and not always relying on social media to do everything,” Szegedi said.
Aside from limits on app times, Bloom explained how reframing thoughts around social media and its impacts on self esteem can be helpful for people. She emphasized the importance of not believing in the illusions that social media creates surrounding people’s lives.
“Everyone should remember that social media is so incredibly fake, and people will curate their accounts and profiles to make them seem like this perfect person,” Bloom said. “Everyone has their own problems going on, and just because they don’t choose to show it doesn’t mean that they’re not struggling or they don’t have something that you think they have.”
Anderson asserts the importance for teens to do all they can to get off their phones and social media, as it harms their ability to simply live for themselves.
“So instead of just going home and going straight to social media, go for a walk, go grocery shopping, go to Starbucks and get your favorite drink, go spend time with friends, go touch grass, just do that stuff, and then you might be happier,” Anderson said.
Illustration by Marika Tighe/Special to Bear Witness




Leave a Reply